Malt Madness focusses mainly on Scotch single malt whisky.
But the world of whisky stretches a lot further. And not just beyond the borders of Scotland, mind you. Single malts are just one kind of whisky; blends and vatted malts are whisky types in their own right. See the
'Beginner's Guide' for more information on this subject.

'Bastard' single malts
(Bottles of unknown origin - single malts according to the label)

47 - Ardnave 10 yrs. (MOD - questionable origin - possibly no real single malt)
43 - Ben Wyvis 10 yrs. (MOD - questionable origin - possibly Tullibardine 10.)
35 - Cockburn 6 yrs. (Questionable origin - possibly Tamdhu)
78 - Ileach n.a.s. (Islay) (Unknown origin - possibly a young Laphroaig)
76 - Macleod's 8 yrs. Island (Unknown origin - possibly Lagavulin 8 yrs.)
75 - Vintage Campbeltown 8 yrs. (2001 bottling - Glen Scotia 8 yrs.)
79 - Vintage Campbeltown 10 yrs. (2002 bottling - Glen Scotia 10 yrs.)
63 - Vintage Highland 7 yrs. (2000 bottling - Longmorn 7 yrs.)
81 - Vintage Islay n.a.s. (1995/96 bottling - no longer available - Lagavulin 6 yrs.)
78 - Vintage Islay 5 yrs. (2000 bottling - Lagavulin 5 yrs.)
81 - Vintage Islay 5 yrs. Cask Strength 58.4% (2000 bottling - Lagavulin 5 yrs.)
54 - Vintage Mull 6 yrs. (2000 bottling - Ledaig 6 yrs.)
72 - Vintage Orkney 7 yrs. (2000 bottling - Highland Park 7 yrs.)
76 - Vintage Skye 8 yrs. (2000 bottling - Talisker 8 yrs.)
82 - Vintage Island 8 yrs. Cask Strength (2001 bottling - Talisker 8 yrs. 57%)

Related remarks and
recommendations

It wasn't before 1997 that I seriously started rating vatted malts, blends, bourbons and the like. It took a few years for my nose and palate to develop sufficiently. Please take into account that I don't take the rating of these whiskies as serious as my nosing and tasting of single malts.

-------------------------

Character and individuality are very important to me - at least where whiskies are concerned. That is why even excellent blends like Chivas Regal Royal Salute and Original Maclinlay 21 yrs. barely meet the 80 points 'great' benchmark. Single malts simply have more 'personality' and 'character' than blends.
And I just don't like the smell and taste of grain whiskies, I guess.

---------------------------

Another point of interest: By their very nature, blended and 'vatted' whiskies can be quite different in different years. After all, blending isn't an exact science. The blender has to combine twenty or more different whiskies to produce a uniform product year after year - not an easy task. One more reason not to take these ratings too seriously.

----------------------

'Typical Johanno-ranges' for
some other beverages:

Beer: 1 - 35
Wine: 5 - 50
Sherry: 10 - 45
Port: 25 - 85
Cognac: 35 - 100
Armagnac: 55 - 95
Calvados: 35 - 85
Grappa: 1 - 30
Rum: 15 - 70
Wodka: 20 - 45
Gin: 10 - 30
Tequila: 1 - 35

Please bear in mind that these ratings are only meant to indicate my personal feelings towards a specific drink. Fine wines are pretty much wasted on me and this is reflected in these personal ratings.

-------------------------

When I'm writing this down one more advantage of single malt whiskies comes to mind; no hangover! Could this have something to do with the absence of grain whisky?

Since I discovered single malts, my consumption of other types of whisky has decreased dramatically. After all; why should I waste my time and money on 'nice' whiskies when I could be drinking great whiskies? Well - hold that thought.... Something can be said for the sampling of an occasional blended whisky or vatted malt. For one thing, It helps me to keep things in perspective. Even the single malts that end up in the 'worst single malts' catagory are usually better than your average blend or vatted malt - with the notable exception of Loch Dhu 10 yrs.

Click HERE to
return to the
liquid log

Scotch vatted malts

48 - Blairmhor 8 yrs
70 - Chivas Regal "100" Century
34 - Glen Green 5 yrs.
41 - Glen Salen
46 - Glen Sloy 5 yrs.
42 - Glen Talloch Pure Malt 8 yrs.
68 - Johnnie Walker 15 yrs. Green Label
38 - MacAllister 8 yrs.
47 - Strathglen 12 yrs.

Scotch blends & grain

37 - Bailie Nicol Jarvie
19 - Ballantine's
05 - Big Blend
29 - Black Barrel (single grain)
71 - Black Bottle 10 yrs.
52 - Chivas Regal 12 yrs.
81 - Chivas Regal Royal Salute
34 - Cutty Sark
07 - The Claymore
40 - Dimple
36 - Famous Grouse
11 - Gold Label Old Whisky
27 - Grant's
24 - House of Lords 12 yrs.
33 - J & B
20 - Johnnie Walker Red Label
60 - Johnnie Walker Black Label
71 - Johnnie Walker Blue Label
50 - Lochranza
15 - MacArthurs's Best Blend
13 - Mansion House
16 - Old Smuggler's
80 - Original Mackinlay 21 yrs.
50 - Teacher's
56 - Teacher's '60'
61 - Teacher's 12 yrs.
49 - Te Bheag
39 - Vat 69
34 - Whyte & Mackay
31 - William Lawson's
26 - YB 'Why Be'

Ireland

53 - Bushmills Malt
34 - Clontarf
49 - Clontarf Reserve
56 - Clontarf Single Malt
78 - Connemara
51 - Jameson
57 - Jameson 12 yrs.
73 - Locke's
47 - Millar's Special Reserve
49 - Paddy
52 - Tullamore Dew
(rating varies)
75 - Tyrconnell

U.S.A. (Bourbon & Rye)

26 - Four Roses
41 - Jack Daniels Old No. 7
37 - Jim Beam
45 - McCormick Platte Valley Corn Whiskey
45 - Old Crow

Canada

19 - Canadian Club
37 - Gooderham & Worts
50 - Lot 40
43 - Pike Creek

New Zealand

70 - Lammerlaw 10 yrs.

Japan

61 - Suntory Kakubin (rating varies)

Liquid LogBig Black BookMalt Madness mAlmanac Hitlist & Shitlist
Go backHomepageIntroductionSitemapHelpContact